• Spain's news in English

Can 'nightmare' of pilot suicide be prevented?

The Local · 26 Mar 2015, 16:13

Published: 26 Mar 2015 16:13 GMT+01:00

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

“If the pilots did not stop the plane from crashing into the mountains, either they were unconscious or dead or they decided to die, or they were forced to die,” said one aviation safety expert this week.

But after French prosecutors revealed on Thursday that 28-year-old co-pilot Andreas Lubitz purposefully locked the pilot out of the cockpit and set the plane on a downward trajectory, the likelihood appears to be that the young German chose to die.

In doing so he killed himself as well as the other 149 people on board, including the plane's captain, who reportedly tried to smash the cockpit door down as the plane plunged towards the Alps.

If this theory is officially confirmed in the days to come it will realise one of the greatest fears of both airlines and passengers alike and raise serious questions about security on board airplanes.

But is it really possible to prevent a pilot from wanting to "destroy" a plane and so many lives with it?

(The interior of an Airbus A320. Photo: Daniel Mennerich/Flickr)

Chief Executive of Lufthansa Carsten Spohr insisted no security "in the world" could protect an airline from the kind of action taken by a co-pilot.

"Whatever safety provisions you have in a company, however high the standards, such an isolated case cannot be completely ruled out," he told reporters. "No system in the world can rule it out."

If Lubitz did deliberately fly the passengers to their deaths, it would not be the first time a pilot has acted in such a devastating way.

In 2013 a Mozambican airlines flight is believed to have crashed for a similar reason, as did a SilkAir flight in 1997 in Indonesia and an Egyptair plane in 1999, that had 217 people on board, although in this case the pilot suicide theory is disputed (see list below).

READ ALSO: What we know about the co-pilot Andreas Lubitz

'Pilots are just like everyone else'

“It might surprise people that pilots, who are very well monitored, are capable of acts that appear to be demented. But pilots are just like other people, some are depressed,” former airline captain Jean-Claude Bück, told BFM TV.

“At Air France there have been cases of pilots committing suicide, but, pardon my expression, they haven’t taken the passengers with them,” said Bück. “One pilot even committed suicide during a stopover in a hotel.”

The impact of the co-pilot’s actions on the commercial aviation industry could be widespread as companies react to heightened fears among passengers.

Since 9/11 doors of the cockpits have been built to withstand grenades and a locking system has allowed pilots to refuse entry to anyone outside.

In the case of the Germanwings flight, that meant that the co-pilot was able to keep the captain out of the cockpit after he left to go to the toilet.

Within hours of the French prosecutor’s press conference, low-cost carrier Norwegian Air Shuttle said it would require two people in the cockpit at all times for safety reasons. That falls in line with a system employed by other airlines, notably in North America.

'Increased psychological monitoring'

One pilot with 44 years experience on major national carriers told The Local that airlines may also introduce increased monitoring of pilots to try and keep a closer check on their psychological state.

"We already do our medicals on a regular basis - for captains it's every six months - and I think that going forward this will probably also include some kind of mental checkups at regular intervals," said the pilot who declined to be named.

"But this wouldn't be something they'd start doing on a regular basis, maybe every second or third year,” he added.

He said that current checkups included only eyesight, hearing, blood tests, heart monitoring, and regular fitness, carried out by specially assigned doctors approved by aviation authorities.

David Gleave, an air accident investigator whose specialty is pilot suicides, told the BBC: "There's all sorts of areas that the psychological specialist will start to look at during the investigation but I certainly think that it's going to be reviewed fairly quickly."

On Thursday Lufthansa staunchly defended the measures it takes to select pilots and its chief executive Carsten Spohr tried to put the crash, however horrific, in some kind of perspective.

"In our worst nightmares we could not have imagined that this kind of tragedy could happen to us here at our company," he said.

"Flying is the most secure form of transport and it is always becoming more secure."

Story continues below…


The website Aviation Safety Network has published a list of recent incidents in which passenger plane crashes have been caused by pilot suicide.

Here are three of the main incidents of suspected pilot murder suicide:

21 August 1994 – 44 fatalities

A Royal Air Maroc ATR-42 airplane crashed in the Atlas Mountains shortly after takeoff from Agadir, Morocco. The accident was suggested to have been caused by the captain disconnecting the autopilot and directing the aircraft to the ground deliberately. The Moroccan Pilot’s Union challenged these findings.  

19 December 1997 – 104 fatalities

Silk Air Flight 185, a Boeing 737 en route from Jakarta, Indonesia to Singapore, crashed in Indonesia following a rapid descent from cruising altitude. Indonesian authorities were not able to determine the cause of the accident. It has been suggested by amongst others the US NTSB that the captain may have committed suicide by switching off both flight recorders and intentionally putting the Boeing 737 in a dive, possibly when the first officer had left the flight deck. During 1997 the captain experienced multiple work-related difficulties, particularly during the last 6 months. Also at the time of the accident the captain was experiencing significant financial difficulties, which was disputed by the Indonesian investigators. 

31 October 1999 – 217 fatalities

Egypt Air Flight 990, a Boeing 767, entered a rapid descent some 30 minutes after departure from New York-JFK Airport. This happened moments after the captain had left the flight deck. During the investigation it was suggested that the accident was caused by a deliberate act by the relief first officer. However, there was no conclusive evidence. The NTSB concluded that the accident was a “result of the relief first officer’s flight control inputs. The reason for the relief first officer’s actions was not determined.” The suggestions of a deliberate act were heavily disputed by Egyptian authorities.

For more news from Spain, join us on Facebook and Twitter.

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Recipe: How to make fabada - traditional Asturian bean stew
Photo: Flavio Lorenzo Sánchez/Flickr

The hearty Asturian dish is a perfect lunch on a cold day... and don't forget the crusty bread and cider!

Brit 'paedo' held on Costa del Sol after Most Wanted appeal

One of Britain's most wanted fugitives was arrested on the Costa Del Sol following a tip-off from an expat just hours after his face appeared on a public appeal.

Spain's parliament approves deficit reduction measures
Photo: Images Money/Flickr

Spanish lawmakers approved on Thursday measures to reduce the public deficit and keep it under the target agreed with the European Union.

'Cubism and War' show opens at Barcelona Picasso Museum
Pablo Picasso Harlequin and Woman with a Necklace. Photo: MP

Barcelona's Picasso Museum unveiled an exhibition on "Cubism and War" on Thursday depicting how one of the most influential artistic styles of the 20th century survived the First World War.

Why this bionic limb pioneer doesn't believe in disability
Hugh Herr has been award Spain's top science prize. Photo: FPA

The Local speaks to Hugh Herr on winning Spain's top science prize and how being an amputee doesn't make him disabled.

Dine in the buff at Spain's first nudist restaurant
A buffet of organic food will be served on "human tables". Photo: Innato / Facebook

Spain's first naked dining experience is to arrive on the island of Tenerife following the success of a similar venture in London.

Spain's top court overturns bullfighting ban in Catalonia
Photo: AFP

Spain's Constitutional Court on Thursday cancelled a bullfighting ban in Catalonia in what is likely to exacerbate tensions between Madrid and the separatist region, and between animal activists and fans of the tradition.

Out of the dark: Five years on from Eta ceasefire
Eta members made a ceasefire declaration in January, 2011. Photo: Gara / AFP

Five years after armed separatist group Eta declared a permanent ceasefire, Basque journalist Alberto Letona is still wondering when the dialogue will begin.

Hunt for ten most wanted Brit fugitives hiding out in Spain
Call Crimestoppers if you recognize these faces.

These fugitives from British justice are thought to be hiding out in Spain. Do you recognize anyone?

Eta 'not dead' but Spain focus moves onto jihadism
Archive photo of a pro-mural in the Basque Country. Photo: AFP

Five years after Eta quit violence, the Basque separatist group has yet to dissolve but it poses little threat and authorities have shifted their focus to fight jihadists, says Spain's chief anti-terrorism prosecutor.

Sponsored Article
How to vote absentee from abroad in the US elections
Madrid parish church faces fine over 'too noisy' bells
Sponsored Article
Last chance to vote absentee in the US elections
Celebrate expat life at Madrid’s THRIVE convention
Fury after kids told to bring their own loo roll to school
Sponsored Article
How to vote absentee from abroad in the US elections
Disney announces plans for Don Quixote action movie
Activist tells 8-yr-old matador wannabe with cancer 'just die'
King to make last minute push to avoid third vote in Spain
Amazing photos of Catalonia's 'human tower' contest
What's on in Spain: October 2016
'No way, Jose! You'll never get your hands on our Rock'
Recipe: How to make a classic Spanish tortilla de patatas
Chorizo in paella? Go back to cooking school Jamie Oliver
Spain in eye of a perfect storm after 10 months without govt
Thousands share clips of life for 'Spain in a Day' film
Ten incredible Spain locations for Game of Thrones season 7
Analysis & Opinion
Why moving to Spain could be the best decision of your life
Seven reasons why autumn is the very best season in Spain
Spanish study finds four types of personality. Which are you?
New search underway for civil war grave of poet Lorca
Bison found decapitated on Valencia nature reserve
Forgotten Voices: What Brits in Spain think about Brexit
One dead and 14 injured in blast at Spanish resort
Game of Thrones want extras 'with muscles' to film in Spain
Thousands march in Madrid to push for bullfighting ban
jobs available