• Spain's news in English

Spain's thalidomide victims lose damages bid

The Local · 22 Oct 2014, 12:30

Published: 22 Oct 2014 12:30 GMT+02:00

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

Madrid’s Provincial Court has blocked the payment of compensation by Grünenthal to 186 Spanish victims of Thalidomide, overturning last year’s decision by a lower court in favour of the plaintiffs having found the company to have been "negligent".

The higher court on Wednesday said that the plaintiffs had not proven sufficient causality between the consumption of a drug made by Grünenthal and the individuals' deformities and it was therefore “overturning the sentence and dismissing the complaint in its entirety”, Spanish daily El Mundo reported.

Among the reasons for the decision were the difficulty in proving that the disabled individuals' birth defects were linked to Thalidomide and the fact that some of the people in the list of victims had not been born during the relevant period at the beginning of the 1960s. The court also said that legal time limits had been overrun.

In November 2013 another Madrid court had ordered Grünenthal to pay damages of €20,000 for every percentage point of disability in each case and to meet the costs of the litigation after ruling that the firm had failed to carry out sufficient laboratory trials of Thalidomide before marketing it in Germany. Grünenthal appealed the ruling.

Thalidomide was marketed in the 1950s as a tranquilizer but was increasingly used to alleviate the symptoms of morning sickness in pregnant women before being withdrawn after a series of births with missing or deformed limbs.

Last year’s court ruling limits compensation payments to those people recognized by the government in a 2010 royal decree as victims of the drug. However, it excluded people who received money from the Contergan Foundation, established in Germany in 1971 to compensate Thalidomide victims and into which Grünenthal paid 117 million deutschmarks.

The Association of Victims of Thalidomide in Spain (Avite) had sought compensation for 186 people totalling €204 million ($259 million).

Avite’s president, José Riquelme, described Wednesday’s ruling as a “hard and low blow” for Spain’s Thalidomide victims.

Story continues below…

“We find it incredible and bizarre that the [lower court judge] did not consider that the case had overrun legal time limits and now three judges from the Madrid Provincial Court do,” Riquelme said. He added that he would continue the legal battle “as long as he had breath in his body”, stating that Avite would appeal this latest ruling.

In a statement provided to The Local, Grünenthal said: "By upholding the appeal, the court has shown that claimants were not able to provide evidence to their pleadings and that a valid trial is impossible after an elapse of more than 50 years."

The company reiterated it continued to support individuals affected by the drug via the Contergan Foundation and other international initiatives. 

For more news from Spain, join us on Facebook and Twitter.

The Local (news@thelocal.es)

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Recipe: How to make fabada - traditional Asturian bean stew
Photo: Flavio Lorenzo Sánchez/Flickr

The hearty Asturian dish is a perfect lunch on a cold day... and don't forget the crusty bread and cider!

Brit 'paedo' held on Costa del Sol after Most Wanted appeal

One of Britain's most wanted fugitives was arrested on the Costa Del Sol following a tip-off from an expat just hours after his face appeared on a public appeal.

Spain's parliament approves deficit reduction measures
Photo: Images Money/Flickr

Spanish lawmakers approved on Thursday measures to reduce the public deficit and keep it under the target agreed with the European Union.

'Cubism and War' show opens at Barcelona Picasso Museum
Pablo Picasso Harlequin and Woman with a Necklace. Photo: MP

Barcelona's Picasso Museum unveiled an exhibition on "Cubism and War" on Thursday depicting how one of the most influential artistic styles of the 20th century survived the First World War.

Why this bionic limb pioneer doesn't believe in disability
Hugh Herr has been award Spain's top science prize. Photo: FPA

The Local speaks to Hugh Herr on winning Spain's top science prize and how being an amputee doesn't make him disabled.

Dine in the buff at Spain's first nudist restaurant
A buffet of organic food will be served on "human tables". Photo: Innato / Facebook

Spain's first naked dining experience is to arrive on the island of Tenerife following the success of a similar venture in London.

Spain's top court overturns bullfighting ban in Catalonia
Photo: AFP

Spain's Constitutional Court on Thursday cancelled a bullfighting ban in Catalonia in what is likely to exacerbate tensions between Madrid and the separatist region, and between animal activists and fans of the tradition.

Out of the dark: Five years on from Eta ceasefire
Eta members made a ceasefire declaration in January, 2011. Photo: Gara / AFP

Five years after armed separatist group Eta declared a permanent ceasefire, Basque journalist Alberto Letona is still wondering when the dialogue will begin.

Hunt for ten most wanted Brit fugitives hiding out in Spain
Call Crimestoppers if you recognize these faces.

These fugitives from British justice are thought to be hiding out in Spain. Do you recognize anyone?

Eta 'not dead' but Spain focus moves onto jihadism
Archive photo of a pro-mural in the Basque Country. Photo: AFP

Five years after Eta quit violence, the Basque separatist group has yet to dissolve but it poses little threat and authorities have shifted their focus to fight jihadists, says Spain's chief anti-terrorism prosecutor.

Sponsored Article
How to vote absentee from abroad in the US elections
Madrid parish church faces fine over 'too noisy' bells
Sponsored Article
Last chance to vote absentee in the US elections
Celebrate expat life at Madrid’s THRIVE convention
Fury after kids told to bring their own loo roll to school
Sponsored Article
How to vote absentee from abroad in the US elections
Disney announces plans for Don Quixote action movie
Activist tells 8-yr-old matador wannabe with cancer 'just die'
King to make last minute push to avoid third vote in Spain
Amazing photos of Catalonia's 'human tower' contest
What's on in Spain: October 2016
'No way, Jose! You'll never get your hands on our Rock'
Recipe: How to make a classic Spanish tortilla de patatas
Chorizo in paella? Go back to cooking school Jamie Oliver
Spain in eye of a perfect storm after 10 months without govt
Thousands share clips of life for 'Spain in a Day' film
Ten incredible Spain locations for Game of Thrones season 7
Analysis & Opinion
Why moving to Spain could be the best decision of your life
Seven reasons why autumn is the very best season in Spain
Spanish study finds four types of personality. Which are you?
New search underway for civil war grave of poet Lorca
Bison found decapitated on Valencia nature reserve
Forgotten Voices: What Brits in Spain think about Brexit
One dead and 14 injured in blast at Spanish resort
Game of Thrones want extras 'with muscles' to film in Spain
Thousands march in Madrid to push for bullfighting ban
jobs available