Catalan vote watchdog quits over bias claims

Steve Tallantyre/The Local/AFP
Steve Tallantyre/The Local/AFP - [email protected]
Catalan vote watchdog quits over bias claims
The Professor of Political Science at UAB said that some instututions were "telling people what their vote should be." Photo:QUIQUE GARCIA/AFP/UAB

Quim Brugué, a member of the commission assembled to manage Catalonia's planned November 9th consultation on independence from Spain, has resigned citing "difficulties" in assuring "neutrality".


Brugué, who  is Professor of Political Science at the Autonomous University of Barcelona (UAB), announced his reasons for resigning  via Twitter on Sunday.

The resignation is personal. I accept all the criticisms but I cannot support a consultation that, in my opinion, does not offer democratic guarantees. 

Brugué had recently been named as one of seven members of a committee put together to help steer the planned November 9th vote on independence from Spain.

He was put forward by a coalition of Catalonia's Green Party and United and Alternative Left (ICV-EUiA).

According to Catalan daily El Periodico, Brugué felt that municipal institutions were too far inclined towards promoting independence instead of defending the right to decide.

He felt that they were "telling people what their vote should be", using as an example the shouts in favour of independence when Catalan President Artur Mas received motions in favour of the consultation from 900 mayors across Catalonia.

Brugué stated, "It seems we would be doing more harm than good if we went forward with a vote under these conditions."

"I have an inkling and a certain suspicion that we are doing some staging and manoeuvring but that we'll end up doing something different to the consultation," he added.

Catalan pro-independence parties declared on Friday that they were "united" on their referendum bid, which threatens to trigger Spain's biggest constitutional crisis in decades.

Proud of their distinct language and culture, many of the 7.5 million inhabitants in the prosperous region have long complained they get a raw deal from the government in Madrid, which decides how their taxes are spent.

They have been fired up by last month's independence referendum in Scotland, even though voters there rejected a separation from Britain. Hundreds of thousands of Catalans have protested in the streets in recent weeks demanding their own vote.

On Friday, Catalonia's government formally decreed the creation of a commission to supervise the ballot, prompting the national conservative government to say it will ask the Constitutional Court to block that decree, just as it has suspended other Catalan legislation this week over the vote.

Spain's opposition Socialists also oppose independence for Catalonia, but have called for a federal constitutional reform to answer Catalan demands.


Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.

Please log in to leave a comment.

See Also