• Spain's news in English
 
app_header_v3

Jesus' crucifixion was legal: Spanish study

George Mills · 11 Nov 2013, 17:21

Published: 11 Nov 2013 17:21 GMT+01:00

The death of Jesus on the cross was not the end result of a thinly veiled legal farce, argues José María Ribas Alba, Professor in Roman Law at Spain’s Seville University in Spain's 20 minutos newspaper.

Instead, Jesus' court case ticked all the boxes for "what we know about the legal criteria of the time".

The law professor has spent 25 years raking over the details of the trial against Jesus and has just released a 300-page study on what he believes is "one of the most important events in history".

His conclusion? The trial was perfectly legal.

In fact, Ribas Alba claims there were two separate but interconnected trials against the historical figure Christians consider the son of God.

One of those involved the Jewish crime of blasphemy while the other related to the Roman crime of lèse majesté, or insulting a monarch or head of state.

But these weren't separate issues. Both were religio-political crimes.

"Religious and political thinking then mixed in a way that is very difficult for people to understand nowadays," says the Spanish legal expert.

To back up his claims about the legality of Jesus' trials, the Spanish professor has compared them with other contemporary legal proceedings.

His lengthy study includes profiles of key figures involved in the trial including the Roman Prefect Pontius Pilate and the Jewish High Priest Caiaphas, who is said to have orchestrated a plot to kill Jesus.

The second part of the study looks at why Jesus’ teachings caused anger among Jewish authorities.

Ribas Alba then examines the so-called Sanhedrin trial of Jesus which saw Jesus tried before a Jewish Council before being passed over to the Roman authorities.

Story continues below…

In the final part of his study, the professor casts an eye over the powers of Pontius Pilate and looks at the connection between blasphemy and lèse majesté.

This is "one of the most important historical events in history" argues the professor, because it involves “a figure who had a decisive influence on world history”.

Jesus "helped configure our culture and the mentality of Western civilization," Ribas Alba concludes.  

The "criminal proceedings against him were legal". 

George Mills (george.mills@thelocal.com)

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Feature
 Spanish cinema breaks taboo and talks ETA
A still from Justin Webster's documentary The End of ETA. Photo: The End of ETA

Documentaries on terror group ETA have been screened at San Sebastian film festival and met with applause, as the taboo fades.

 Spain's Socialists in crisis as political blockage takes toll
Pedro Sanchez has repeatedly said he won't support Rajoy. Photo: AFP

Spain's nine-month political paralysis is taking its toll on parties, and none more so than the Socialists who are facing a crisis, with talk of an imminent "coup" against leader Pedro Sanchez.

National anthem: Could Spain finally sing with one voice?
Spanish athletes have had to hum awkwardly for decades. Photo: AFP

Spain's parliament is being asked to consider a solution to one of nation's most enduring and embarrassing problems; what words to sing with the national anthem.

Spain's ten greatest parador hotels to visit this autumn
San Estevo parador in Galicia. Photo: rutea.es

Autumn is the perfect time to explore Spain's hidden corners and parador hopping is the best way to do it.

Spain's Basques go to polls as memories of violence fade
Basque regional president nationalist Inigo Urkullu (L) and Basque Nationalist Party-PNV's president Andoni Ortuzar (2nd L) in Bilbao. Photo: AFP

Could the results of the Basque elections have an impact on the national political deadlock?

Spanish parents call strike over too much homework
Do Spanish children get too much homework? Photo: AFP

Spanish parents have called for a “homework strike” to protest at the amount of extracurricular work they are expected to do with their children.

Family seeks funds for mother injured in Spanish bus crash
Julie Ann Fiegert was returning from a holiday of a lifetime. Photo: GoFundMe page

The family of an Australian woman left fighting for her life after a bus accident in Spain are trying to raise money for her medical expenses.

Second headless bison found at Spanish nature reserve

A mystery surrounding goings-on at a nature reserve in Spain deepened Thursday as a second European bison was found decapitated just days after staff discovered the headless body of the herd's dominant male.

San Sebastian Film Festival
Obama-era surveillance worse than Stasi, says Oliver Stone
Oliver Stone in San Sebastian on Thursday. Photo: AFP

US film director Oliver Stone on Thursday accused President Barack Obama's administration of implementing a surveillance system worse than that of the feared Stasi secret police in East Germany.

Car-Free Day brings traffic to a standstill across Spain
Car Free Day meant more traffic jams for some. Photo: Marina Roch / Twitter

Traffic was brought to a standstill with lengthly traffic jams reported across cities in Spain as an initiative to boost awareness of rising air pollution backfired.

National
Seven reasons why autumn is the very best season in Spain
International
Spanish study finds four types of personality. Which are you?
National
New search underway for civil war grave of poet Lorca
National
Bison found decapitated on Valencia nature reserve
International
Forgotten Voices: What Brits in Spain think about Brexit
Travel
One dead and 14 injured in blast at Spanish resort
International
Game of Thrones want extras 'with muscles' to film in Spain
Sponsored Article
Why Jordan is the ‘Different’ East
Thousands march in Madrid to push for bullfighting ban
Technology
Spanish team invents hands-free 'penis bidet'
National
In pics: Devastation caused by Costa Blanca wildfires
Society
Pregnant woman in niqab attacked by two men in Spain
National
Spanish café offers cut-price coffee to those with manners
Travel
What's on in Spain: September 2016
Travel
'We drank from animal troughs to survive'
National
Forest fires threaten Costa Blanca resort of Jávea
National
Loyal dog mounts vigil at hospital doors for sick owner
Politics
Five reasons why Spain's Socialists won't back Rajoy
National
It's a girl! Rare giant panda cub born in Madrid zoo
Culture
La Tomatina: Everything you need to know about epic fiesta
National
Shocking video shows torture of young calf during fiesta
Police launch appeal for Costa Blanca hit and run driver
Politics
What political deadlock? Spain economy forges ahead
Features
Eight reasons to spend your gap year exploring Spain
3,104
jobs available