Spain wage cut talk ‘was misunderstood’: EU

Recent comments by the European Commission's Vice President about a possible 10 percent wage cut in Spain were misinterpreted, sources at the Commission told have The Local.

Spain wage cut talk 'was misunderstood': EU
European Commissioner Olli Rehn earns just under €23,000 a month, equal to the average annual salary in Spain. Photo: Georges Gobet/AFP

European Commissioner Olli Rehn raised ire among Spain's unions, employer groups and political parties with a blog piece he published on Wednesday.

In the blog entry, the Finn appeared to give his support to an International Monetary Fund (IMF) model which would see Spain slashing wages by 10 percent to trigger economic growth and tackle unemployment in the country.

But a senior source at the European Commission has told The Local the Vice President's comments have been misinterpreted.

Rehn's "intention was to encourage a wider discussion around the issues regarding the economy in Spain". the European Commission source said.

That source was also keen to stress that  the commissioner "was not making any new, prescriptive recommendations for Spain".

Those prescriptive measures were contained instead in the Commission's Country-specific Recommendations, the source said, adding that the recommendations had also been accepted by Spain. 

That document advises Spain to bring its budget deficit below 3 percent of GDP by 2016 through "expenditure restraint" and "revenue-increasing" measures.

The European Commission also said the Vice President's blog, which cited the examples of Ireland and Latvia, was about "encouraging all political and social stakeholders in Spain to look into other experiences in Europe with an open mind".

Rehn was not saying Spain should follow Ireland and Latvia's lead, but that the country should consider other experiences when determining its "policy mix".

The Commission's comments to The Local come in the wake of an angry response to Rehn's blog piece.

Fernando Lezcan, Secretary for Organization and Communications from the general workers union the CCOO, said Rehn's statements were "completely unacceptable" both because the IMF proposal wouldn't help Spain emerge from the crisis and for the suffering the plan would cause.

Meanwhile Elena Valenciano, second-in-command with Spain's opposition socialist PSOE party likened Rehn's support for the IMF plan to a "poisoned dart", saying "salary cuts and tax rises had made Spaniards far poorer".

"There are millions of workers (in Spain) who earn in a month what Rehn spends on two dinners," said the PSOE Vice Secretary.

The European Commissioner — also the European Commissioner for Economic and Monetary Affairs and the Euro —  earns just under €23,000 a month.

This is equal to the average annual salary in Spain, also slightly below €23,000 a year, Spain's stats office the INE said in late June.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


Spain court orders ex-IMF head Rato to be tried for fraud

A Spanish court on Friday ordered former IMF head Rodrigo Rato to stand trial for fraud over the failed 2011 listing of Bankia, a bank he led which later needed rescuing by the state.

Spain court orders ex-IMF head Rato to be tried for fraud
Rodrigo Rato is accused of falsifying information about Bankia's finances. Photo: Gerard Julien/AFP

Rato, a former Spanish economy minister, is accused of falsifying information about Bankia's finances to encourage investors to buy into its stock market listing.

He will stand trial along with 30 other former Bankia executives for investor fraud and for falsifying 2010 and 2011 accounts, Spain's High Court said in its ruling.

The court will also put Bankia itself and its parent company BFA on trial over the failed listing, as well as accounting firm Deloitte and one of its employees. Deloitte audited the lender's accounts.

Bankia was rescued in 2012, less than a year after it was listed, and tens of thousands of small investors who had converted their savings to shares lost everything.

The near-collapse of Bankia almost brought down Spain's whole financial sector, which was bailed out later that year by international creditors for 41 billion euros ($48 billion).

Last year, the Supreme Court ruled that “serious inaccuracies” in the information provided by Bankia misled investors.

When Rato was questioned in court in 2012 over the Bankia listing, he reiterated his claims that Spanish authorities held responsibility for events at the lender including the timing of its ill-fated stock market flotation.

Struggling financially

Public prosecutors in June asked that Rato, 68, be given a five-year jail sentence over the Bankia listing.

They have argued that as the bank's “main executive,” he was “fully aware of the inconsistency of the Bankia project and of its financial weakness” but still gave the green light for the listing.

Bankia was created in 2010 by merging seven regional savings banks, part of a financial sector shake-up brought on by the collapse of a construction boom that dragged Spain into a severe recession.

Last year, the bank said it had paid out €1.2 billion in compensation to 190,000 small investors, but added it still had about 30,000 claims pending.

Rato was sentenced in February to four years and six months in a separate case for misusing funds when he was the boss of Bankia, and Caja Madrid before that.

Rato and the other executives were accused of having paid for personal expenses with credit cards put at their disposal by the lenders, without ever justifying them or declaring them to tax authorities.

These expenses included petrol for their cars, supermarket shopping, pricey holidays, luxury bags or parties in nightclubs.


The case caused an outrage in Spain, where it was uncovered at the height of a severe economic crisis that left many people struggling financially – made all the worse because Bankia later had to be nationalised.

Rato denied any wrongdoing and said the credit cards were for discretionary spending as part of executives' pay.

He was allowed to remain free and without judicial supervision pending a final verdict in the case.

Rato was economy minister and deputy prime minister in the conservative government of Jose Maria Aznar from 1996 to 2004, before going on to head the International Monetary Fund until 2007.

He is the third former IMF chief to get into trouble with the law.

His successor Dominique Strauss-Kahn was tried in 2015 on pimping charges in a lurid sex scandal, and was acquitted.

And Christine Lagarde, who took over from Strauss-Kahn and is the current IMF chief, was found guilty of negligence over a massive state payout to a tycoon when she was French finance minister, though she received no penalty.

By Emmanuelle Michel