Spaniards rail at Bankia as savings evaporate

Spanish savers vented their fury against bailed-out Bankia on Friday after the already-diminished value of their stock investments in the bank plummeted by more than half in a single day.

Spaniards rail at Bankia as savings evaporate
"Thieves", "bastards", cried a group of protesters who gathered outside the court as the bank chiefs arrived. Photo: Pedro Armestre/AFP
The stock market regulator, the CNMV, said it would examine trading in Bankia shares on Thursday, when the value of the stock plunged 51.4 percent to just €0.68 ($0.88) in brisk trade.
By coincidence, the market rout came a day before chiefs of Spain's biggest banks came to testify as witnesses at the National Court in Madrid about Bankia's ill-fated listing in July 2011.
"Thieves", "bastards", cried a group of protesters who gathered outside the court as the bank chiefs arrived.

Bankia president Jose Ignacio Goirigolzarri told radio Cope he welcomed the regulator's inquiry into Thursday's trading, which he could not explain. "It is difficult to understand, I don't understand it," he said.

The Bankia boss said he suspected institutions had engaged in short-selling, in which traders bet that a stock price will fall. The Spanish daily El Mundo also reported several banks had engaged in short selling.

As the price collapsed, many small investors called their bank branches wanting to sell their Bankia shares, but were told they had to wait until Tuesday, Spanish media said. In theory individual investors could have sold their shares on Thursday, said Soledad Pellon, strategist at brokerage house IG Markets.

"But they don't know these practices. Institutional investors are much better informed about all the possibilities," Pellon said, adding that she believed the trade was legal.

Another brokerage house, Link Securities, said it believed the short-selling flouted Spanish regulations. "These sharp drop puts small shareholders in a weaker position because they can't sell and now face heavy losses," the group said.

On Tuesday, Bankia will boost its share capital by 15.54 billion euros, which had been expected to lead to an average loss of 36-38 percent for existing shareholders. Thursday's slump makes those losses much greater, however.

The investigation into the share trading comes as the courts investigate the original listing of Bankia nearly two years ago, with 33 bank officials suspected of fraud, embezzlement and providing false annual accounts.

As part of the probe, Santander president Emilio Botin, BBVA chief Francisco Gonzalez and CaixaBank boss Isidro Faine were called to testify to the court about meetings held in May 2012 with Economy Minister Luis de Guindos and then Bankia president Rodrigo Rato just ahead of his resignation.

"Bankia was the bull in the china shop," said BBVA's Gonzalez, according to a legal source who was present during the testimony. "We did not tackle the problem in time."

Born in 2010 from the merger of seven troubled savings banks, Bankia soon became a symbol of Spain's banking crisis and the huge loans that turned sour after a 2008 property crash.

In May 2012, the BFA-Bankia group said it needed 19 billion euros to shore up its books, prompting Spain to seek a 100-billion-euro rescue loan for the entire industry from Brussels. So far, 41.3 billion euros of the rescue have been disbursed. 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


Spain has a new ‘mega bank’ as La Caixa and Bankia merger approved

Directors from CaixaBank and Bankia Thursday approved their merger into Spain's biggest lender in a move which will transform the landscape of Spanish banking.

Spain has a new 'mega bank' as La Caixa and Bankia merger approved
Photos: AFP

A source close to the deal said the board of directors of both banks approved the merger, details of which will be made public on Friday.    

The negotiations involved Bankia's biggest shareholder, the Spanish government.

The merger creates the country's largest bank with combined assets of around €664 billion ($787 billion) in Spain, Renta 4 Banco analysts say, putting the new entity ahead of Santander or BBVA, both of which have a more international presence.

Under terms of the deal, shareholders in CaixaBank, Spain's largest domestic bank, would hold 75 percent of the new entity, while Bankia shareholders would take the remaining 25 percent.

The Spanish state, which currently holds just under 62 percent of Bankia, will hold a 14-percent share in the new group, press reports said.   

In 2012, the Spanish government stepped in to save Bankia from collapse, spending 22 billion euros ($26 billion at current exchange rates) to bail out a bank that was seen as a symbol of financial excess at a time when the Spanish economy was mired in crisis.

The huge merger comes in a very difficult economic context for Spain which has been particularly badly hit by the coronavirus pandemic, with gross domestic product collapsing by 18.5 percent in the second quarter.

The deal should enable the two banks to reduce costs and offers them “a way of trying to improve profitability,” said Xavier Vives of the IESE Business School.


Job cuts loom

Another advantage of the merger is the geographical footprint of each bank, with Bankia more present in Madrid and in the centre of the country, while CaixaBank is well-established in the northeastern Catalonia region, said Robert Tornabell, a banking specialist at ESADE business school.

The financial structure of the deal will allow CaixaBank to access tax breaks worth “several billion” euros, thus providing the new bank the wherewithal to “finance staff restructuring and branch closures,” he said.

Press reports suggested the takeover would result in nearly 8,000 jobs being axed. The two banks currently employ 51,000 staff spread across 6,000 branches.

Despite the staffing issues and the competition concerns raised by the deal, which will create a bank that will manage nearly a third of all Spain's home loans, the Spanish government has welcomed the tie-up.

“There is a process under way,” Economy Minister Nadia Calvino said last week, pointing out that the European authorities have long been encouraging consolidation in the banking sector.


Recovering taxpayers' money

“With this deal, the government is getting rid of one big headache,” the Cinco Dias business daily said recently.

Since the Bankia bailout, the government has been trying to offload its 61.8 stake in the bank but economic context has never been right. For now, it has only managed to recover 3.3 billion euros of the 22-billion payout.   

Even if its stake in the new entity will be reduced to just 14 percent, that should bring in more money to the state coffers because the new bank will be much more profitable.

However, it will take “several years” for the state get back a sum which will not end up being very much, Tornabell said.   

The tie-up will mean the name Bankia disappears from the high street — a name associated with multiple scandals, particularly that of its floatation in 2011 which attracted thousands of small shareholders who faced ruin several months later when the share price collapsed.

Several months later, the government stepped in and the bank was nationalised.

Bankia's former management team is currently on trial for fraud and falsifying its balance sheet ahead of the failed floatation and if convicted over the scandal, former boss Rodrigo Rato is facing eight-and-a-half years behind bars.

The court is expected to reach a verdict soon.

By AFP's Emmanuelle Michel