• Spain's news in English
 
app_header_v3
One year since the Alps plane crash
Germanwings probe: No conclusions 'anytime soon'
Memorial in Haltern for Germanwings crash victims. Photo: Marcel Kusch/DPA

Germanwings probe: No conclusions 'anytime soon'

AFP · 25 Mar 2016, 08:28

Published: 25 Mar 2016 08:28 GMT+01:00

Despite a quick start and rapid revelations over the cause of the crash, it has been harder pinning down who can be held criminally responsible, with the question of doctor-patient confidentiality at the heart of the case.

Hardly an hour and a half after the plane crashed into the French Alps on March 24, 2105, Marseille prosecutor Brice Robin overflew the site. The plane was shattered into such small pieces that they were difficult to discern from the air.

But the black box voice and flight recorders were quickly recovered virtually intact and it was swiftly revealed that 27-year-old co-pilot Andreas Lubitz deliberately crashed the plane, killing all 144 passengers and six crew, mostly from Spain and Germany. 

Although Lubitz cannot be brought to justice for murder, Germanwings, a low-cost subsidiary of Frankfurt-based Lufthansa, could bear some responsibility for the disaster.

Three months after the crash, a three-judge panel in Marseille launched an investigation against unknown persons for manslaughter.

A central issue is that of reconciling doctor-patient confidentiality with
the responsibility of an airline for the lives of its passengers.

French prosecutors said Lubitz, who suffered from psychosis, was terrified of losing his sight and consulted 41 different doctors in the previous five years, including psychiatrists as well as ear, throat and nose specialists.

German prosecutors said a search of Lubitz's flat had found medical
documents, including a torn-up sick leave note from the day of the crash, which supported "the assumption that the deceased had concealed his illness from his employer."

The Marseille probe is complicated by the fact that German rules governing companies' responsibilities are different, as is the treatment of the violation of doctor-patient responsibility. 

The French investigators called earlier this month for "clearer rules" on
the lifting of medical confidentiality if pilots show signs of psychological
problems.

In their final conclusions on the disaster, French civil aviation experts
recommended more stringent medical checks for pilots, but stopped short of suggesting changes to the current system of flight deck door locks, which can only be opened by the pilot in the cockpit.

Story continues below…

German investigators are conducting a parallel probe, but are still bogged down in translation and evaluation of French prosecutors' documents, and said in March a "conclusion is not expected anytime soon."

Meanwhile impatient relatives are planning to sue the airline's parent company Lufthansa in the United States, claiming that Lubitz should never have been allowed to fly a plane.

"The only thing that interests me is that we find whoever... failed to prevent Lubitz from flying a plane," said Annette Bless, whose daughter Elena died in the tragedy, a day before she would have turned 16.

For more news from Spain, join us on Facebook and Twitter.

Today's headlines
Franco finally stripped of mayor title by Catalan town
Spanish dictator Francisco Franco. Photo: AFP

Better late than never...

Why Nigeria is furious over Spain's wasteful tomato fiesta
Nigerians in the grip of a tomato blight are furious over Spanish wastefulness. Photo: AFP

A small town in eastern Spain has become the object of derision from Nigeria for its shocking wastefulness of tomatoes for the sole pursuit of fun.

Police sieze haul of elephant tusks from Madrid home
74 elephant tusks were discovered in the home. Photo: Spanish Civil Guard.

The Spanish Civil Guard discovered 74 elephant tusks at a residence in Madrid.

Stunning cave paintings found 300 metres below Spain
Archeologist Diego Garate with the cave paintings in Atxurra. Photo: bizkaia.eus

The once in a generation find has been hailed as one of Spain’s most important prehistoric discoveries.

Spain has 58 bathing spots that don't meet EU standards
Photo: AFP

But don't worry there are 1,821 bathing spots that meet the excellent quality standard.

Fleet of jets take Madrid fans to Champions League final
Atlético Madrid fans. Photo: Gerard Julien/AFP

More than 200 charter flights have been laid on to take fans to Milan for the all-Madrid final of the Champions League.

DNA from ancient Phoenician shows Iberian ancestry
Young Man of Byrsa. Reconstruction: University of Otago

The man likely came from modern day Spain or Portugal, researchers have revealed.

Pole dancer from Spain makes bid for British stardom
Saulo Sarmiento is a pole dancer for Cirque Du Soleil. Screen grab: Britain's Got Talent/YouTube

Saulo Sarmiento got pulses racing during his audition for Britain's Got Talent, but who is the man behind the moves?

Police backtrack over fine for 'All Cats Are Beautiful' bag
The offending bag and the fine issued over it. Photo: Bélen Lobeto

Police have admitted that perhaps the phrase "All Cats Are Beautiful" isn't quite as offensive as first thought.

Brit historian Mary Beard wins prestigious Spanish award
The award will go nicely with Beard's OBE (pictured above). Photo: John Stillwell/AFP

The British academic is to follow in the footsteps of Sir David Attenborough, Bob Dylan and Margaret Atwood.

Lifestyle
Top Ten: Barcelona's coolest rooftop bars
Sponsored Article
Eat, learn, live: unforgettable holidays in France
National
Plane forced to dodge THREE drones to land in Bilbao
National
Spain launches campaign to stop English 'invasion'
Culture
Ten unique Basque words you need to learn right now
National
'It’s time to dig up Franco' say victims of Spain's dictatorship
Lifestyle
'Severe jellyfish stings' end Brit's Spanish swim feat
Sport
5 reasons why Spanish clubs dominate European football
International
Tesco to bring British tea and biscuits to Spanish stores
Culture
Bucket list: 16 brilliant things to do once in your life in Spain
National
Spain's Civil War victims to be exhumed from Franco's tomb
National
Two mums face jail for leaving kids in car to go out drinking
Education
Students at Spanish college forced to take exorcism class
National
Ten superb reasons why you need to visit San Sebastián
Society
Abused wife saved by hiding SOS note in son's homework
National
Look up! Rare meteor shower set to dazzle skies over Spain
Politics
Why Spain is heading for a Groundhog day election
Travel
Ibiza bans drinking in street… and that includes water
National
Expats didn't 'abandon' UK so ALL Brits should get EU vote
Features
What's on in Spain: May 2016
Travel
Discover Spain's breathtaking national parks
National
Couple caught on camera having sex on metro platform
National
Spain's stunning locations for Game of Thrones Season Six
National
Ten delicious Spanish dishes you must try before you die
3,357
jobs available