• Spain edition
 
Spain fines Google €900,000 in privacy row
File photo: Sam Yeh/AFP

Spain fines Google €900,000 in privacy row

Published: 19 Dec 2013 16:15 GMT+01:00
Updated: 19 Dec 2013 16:15 GMT+01:00

Spain's data protection agency has slapped tech giant Google with a €900,000 ($1.23 million) fine for mishandling personal data.

The Spanish Agency for Data Protection (AEPD) said Google had committed three serious breaches of Spain's privacy law with each of those infractions being fined to the tune of €300,000.

Google had illegally collected and used personal data via over 100 services in Spain without adequately informing about users what that information would be used for, the AEPD stated.

In its ruling, the agency cited the example of Google's failure to advise users of the Gmail email service that email messages and attachments would be 'filtered' so that the firm could insert individualized publicity.

The AEPD said Google's new privacy policy of 2012 "lacked clarity" and "that it overstepped by a long way the reasonable expectations of the average user".  

The data protection agency also took Google to task for using terms like "will be able to" or "it is possible that" in its privacy rules.

It also accused Google of keeping the data for longer than is legally justified and of making it difficult for users to query the use of their data.

Google has repeatedly stated that its privacy policy respects European law, despite investigations in several countries.

Google spokespeople could not immediately be reached to comment to AFP on Thursday but El Pais newspaper quoted the company as saying it had been "totally involved" in the agency's investigations.

It would "read the report carefully and then decide what steps to take next", the newspaper quoted Google as saying.

The Spanish authority launched proceedings against Google in June. In September, France too said it would take action against the company, accusing it of breaching privacy norms.

Authorities in Germany, Italy, The Netherlands and Britain have also opened parallel procedures against Google.

The Spanish agency said it was the first of these six authorities to make a final decision on action against the US giant.

The European Union warned Google in October 2012 that its new data protection procedures did not comply with an EU directive on the subject and gave the company four months to change them.

That deadline passed without any action, prompting France to set up the task force of individual member states pursuing the issue with Google.

Google has defended the changes it made last year, saying they simplify and standardize its approach across its various services.

Critics say the policy gives the operator of the world's largest search engine unprecedented ability to monitor its users.

Like other technology giants, Google has come under heightened scrutiny in recent months following revelations by US whistleblower Edward Snowden of online eavesdropping by intelligence agencies.

The Spanish Data Protection Agency is a state body with power to impose fines and to order data to be destroyed, according to its website.

In 2010 it filed a suit against Google for allegedly capturing data from Internet users when it collected photos for its Street View map service.

Don't miss stories about Spain, join us on Facebook and Twitter.

George Mills (george.mills@thelocal.com)

Don't miss...X
Left Right

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Police chief sacked over Madrid demo turned ugly
Police officers found themselves surrounded and isolated by small groups of violent demonstrators and could not received help from other agents, Spain's top police official explained. Photo: Pedro Arm

Police chief sacked over Madrid demo turned ugly

The head of the anti-riot squad involved a March demonstration in Madrid which turned violent will be removed from his post because of the "intolerable" number of police injured during the event, Spanish authorities said on Wednesday. READ () »

Spanish Face of the Week
Judge sells suppers and shirts for campaign cash
Judge Elpidio José Silva is currently suspended after sending a friend of the former Spanish PM to jail. Photo: Wikimedia

Judge sells suppers and shirts for campaign cash

A controversial Spanish anti-corruption judge who is standing as a candidate in May's European elections is selling everything from autographs to coffee-side chats in a bid to raise cash for his campaign. READ () »

Spain revises up growth forecast for 2014–15
Economy Minister Luis de Guindos. File photo: Johannes Eisele/AFP

Spain revises up growth forecast for 2014–15

Spain's government forecast Wednesday faster economic growth in the next two years as the nation emerges from a long downturn with unemployment still topping 26 percent. READ () »

VIDEO: Virgin falls from float in Easter fail
The religious revellers rocked too enthusiastically and caused the Virgin to take a tumble. Screen Grab: YouTube

VIDEO: Virgin falls from float in Easter fail

One of the 28 Easter parades held in Spain's Alicante province last week took an unexpected turn when a statue of the Virgen de los Dolores toppled from her float and almost landed on the heads of her bearers. READ () »

Lost Spanish temple reveals scientific secrets
The light of the moon and the rising sun shines onto the temple walls to reveal hidden symbols. Photo: Flickr/ Juan Fco. Marrero

Lost Spanish temple reveals scientific secrets

A mysterious cave-temple built by the original inhabitants of the Spanish Island of Gran Canaria contains evidence of their advanced knowledge of astronomy, a Spanish archaeologist believes. READ () »

Moody's backs Spain's 'improving' economy
Spain's public finances are said to be "on a gradually improving trend" but "still comparatively weak". Photo: Grumo/Flickr

Moody's backs Spain's 'improving' economy

Credit rating agency Moody's said on Tuesday that Spain is "now firmly on an improving trend" with exports boosting the eurozone's fourth-biggest economy as it crawls out of recession. READ () »

Want citizenship? Take the Spanish culture test
Currently individual judges in Spain set their own criteria for assessing whether applicants should be awarded Spanish citizenship. Photo: Alberto G./Flickr

Want citizenship? Take the Spanish culture test

Immigrants to Spain will have to sit standardized online language and culture tests before being granted citizenship, Spain's justice minister announced in the country national parliament on Tuesday. READ () »

Spain loses asylum seeker deportation battle
The asylum seekers claimed that they have faced physical torture and sexual abuse in the past due to their ethnic origin. Photo: Dominique Faget/AFP

Spain loses asylum seeker deportation battle

The European Court of Human Rights ruled on Tuesday that Spain could not go ahead with plans to deport 30 Sahrawi asylum seekers from the Western Sahara because Spanish authorities had failed to properly hear their claims. READ () »

Independence website pushes Catalonia cause
The homepage of the Catalonia votes website features a clock which counts down the days, hours and minutes until the planned vote on the issue of self-rule for the wealthy region.

Independence website pushes Catalonia cause

Supporters of an independent Catalonia have stepped up their bid for international backing by launching a new website promoting the cause. The Local spoke to the organization behind the site to find out more. READ () »

Police nab Spain's 'Willy Wonka' drug chef
'Més Que Un Club': The seized sweets in the shape of Barcelona FC's crest contained a coctail of drugs. Photo: Policia Nacional

Police nab Spain's 'Willy Wonka' drug chef

Spanish police have arrested a master 'turrón' (nougat) maker accused of concocting chocolates, formed in the shape of FC Barcelona's club crest, which contained the secret ingredients of magic mushrooms and marijuana. READ () »

RECEIVE OUR NEWSLETTER AND ALERTS
National
Thieves destroy ancient rock painting in Spain
Society
Spain to open first gay old people's home
National
'Monkey Jesus' restorer to star in music video
Culture
Seven surprising facts about Spain's Holy Week
National
Spanish tax office sells bras for extra cash
Society
Abortion Travel: 'The agency that should never exist'
National
Top expat moans about Spain on Twitter
Society
Email gaffe reveals how Spanish firms exploit young workers
National
Man hacks off own fingers in insurance scam
Travel & Tourism
Top ten: Spain's best beaches 2014
National
Lovemaking lands woman at bottom of well
International
Jobless Spaniards to be kicked out of Germany
Sponsored Article
Why it pays to avoid banks when making overseas transfers
Health
Serial texter suffers first case of 'WhatsAppitis'
Politics
Six reasons why Suárez is Spain's best loved PM
Politics
'Energy giants out to kill off Spain's solar sector'
Society
Spain's hottest jobs 2014
National
Man dies while taking selfie on top of train
Society
Spanish PM turns down free English course
Travel & Tourism
Top Ten: Spain's coolest hotels 2014
Culture
A to Z of The Local's picture galleries
Culture
Scientists discover why some of us 'hate' music
Features
How Barcelona is getting it wrong on cannabis
National
'Spain could be a world leader in solar power'
Latest news from The Local in Switzerland

More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch

Latest news from The Local in Germany

More news from Germany at thelocal.de

Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Latest news from The Local in Italy

More news from Italy at thelocal.it

Latest news from The Local in Norway

More news from Norway at thelocal.no

Latest news from The Local in Sweden

More news from Sweden at thelocal.se

1,395
jobs available