• Spain's news in English
 

Court hammers prof for copying student's work

George Mills · 1 Apr 2013, 17:26

Published: 01 Apr 2013 17:26 GMT+02:00

Spain's Supreme Court said the professor will have to hand the student €5,000 after he plagiarized her doctoral work.

The court found that the professor from the University of Murcia — known only as Francisco A.E. for legal reasons — had copied content from a doctoral thesis he originally supervised.   

The judgement came after the professor at the University of Murcia appealed an earlier decision in Valencia's provincial court, reported ABC newspaper on Monday.

The money is compensation for the violation of intellectual property rights said Supreme Court judge Ignacio Sancho in his sentence.

The doctorate in question, by María Isabel G., and titled 'Civil responsibility derived from the issue prospectus of negotiable securites', was submitted in 1998.

She received top marks and the work went on to be published in 2001.

Then, six years later, Francisco A.E published an article with similar subject material.

The professor's ex-student claimed, though, that the article duplicated some of her own work.

But the professor defended himself by saying he had actually drawn up the article before María Isabel handed in her doctoral work in 1998.

Story continues below…

The professor presented the court with an annotated document which he said proved he had written the work first and then passed this to his student for her information.

The judges, however, upheld the version of the student who claimed she had written the text and then passed it on to her doctoral supervisor for corrections.

In his sentence, Judge Ignacio Sancho also said news of the professor's plagiarism would be published in a national newspaper "without commentary or footnotes".

George Mills (george.mills@thelocal.com)

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
US to extradite Salvadoran colonel over Jesuit murders
A procession to commemorate the victims. Photo: Marvin Recinos / AFP

US to extradite Salvadoran colonel over Jesuit murders
20 hours ago

A US judge on Friday approved the extradition to Spain of a Salvadoran former colonel linked to the 1989 murders of six Jesuit priests, in a decision lauded by rights groups.

The Local list
Ten great Spanish films you need to watch now
Photo: Estudios Picasso/IMDB

Ten great Spanish films you need to watch now
21 hours ago

As Spain looks forward to its biggest film award show of the year, The Local counts down Spain's greatest ever movies.

Spanish government stuck in limbo as coalition talks stall
Photo: AFP

Spanish government stuck in limbo as coalition talks stall
1 day ago

Party leaders are struggling to break the deadlock with no indications that a compromise can be struck.

Airbnb poses 'biggest threat' insists Spanish tourism chief
Photo: AFP

Airbnb poses 'biggest threat' insists Spanish tourism chief
1 day ago

A hotel chain boss has lashed out at the home rental websites for "killing the exemplary tourism model".

The Local list
Six Spanish secrets on how to live to the age of a hundred
Ana María Vela, 114, is Spain's oldest resident. Screenshot Youtube

Six Spanish secrets on how to live to the age of a hundred
1 day ago

Just what is the secret to Spaniards' longevity?

Australian hands over €100K to 'boyfriend' in Spanish scam
Photo: Raja Syazwina/Flickr

Australian hands over €100K to 'boyfriend' in Spanish scam
1 day ago

The woman was scammed out of €100,000 believing she was paying her fictitious boyfriend's medical costs.

Misled shareholders file class action lawsuit against Bankia
Protestors demonstrate against Bankia. Photo: AFP

Misled shareholders file class action lawsuit against Bankia
1 day ago

More than 600 small shareholders are suing the bank for misleading them to convert their savings to shares.

Could this be the last gasp for smoking in Spanish cinema?
Screen grab: aalexjander/YouTube

Could this be the last gasp for smoking in Spanish cinema?
1 day ago

Spanish films feature four times as much smoking as those in Hollywood.

The Local list
Ten of Spain's most romantic getaways for Valentine's Day
Photo: Farid Iqbal Ibrahim/Flickr

Ten of Spain's most romantic getaways for Valentine's Day
1 day ago

From sunset strolls to fireside cosiness Spain offers the perfect setting to woo your sweetheart. Here are some of our favourites.

Retrial ordered for Spaniard after 15 years on death row
Pablo Ibar has spent 22 years behind bars.Photo: AFP

Retrial ordered for Spaniard after 15 years on death row
1 day ago

The top court in Florida has ordered a retrial for the triple murders more than two decades ago.

Sponsored Article
US taxes and FATCA: 'The time for hiding is over'
National
UK rallies expats in Spain ahead of referendum on Brexit
National
Secret to long life? Spaniard lived to 107 on 'red wine diet'
National
Ten Spanish corruption scandals that will take your breath away
National
Watch: Gravity-defying stunts at Spain's Wind Tunnel Games
National
10 English words you'd never guess were really Spanish
National
Madrid to rename Francoist streets after terrorism victims
National
Olé? Bullfighter takes five-month-old baby into the ring
National
Watch: Moment south Spain struck by 6.3 magnitude quake
Travel
9 charming Spanish towns to visit before the tourists come
National
Heartbroken parents publish suicide note from bullied son
National
Spain launches new reality TV show: 'I want to be a nun'
National
Eleven very good reasons to be happy you live in Spain
National
Loyal dog waits two months at hospital door for dead owner
Younger, scruffier, and with a babe in arms: This is Spain's new elite
National
Ten adrenaline-fuelled adventures for thrill-seekers in Spain
National
Ten things you need to know about the new president of Catalonia
National
Spain's Princess Cristina: From fairy tale life to national 'baddie'
Politics
Seven reasons why forming a new government is mission impossible
National
Eight essential ways to tackle the winter months like a true Spaniard
National
How to be a mermaid: Swimming academy makes a splash in Spain
Lifestyle
10 resolutions to make the most of life in Spain in 2016
National
Spain’s public holidays in 2016: Official list
Features
Black diamonds: How a corner of Spain became world's truffle capital
2,937
jobs available